How Does a SAFE Convert in a Down Round or Acquisition?
When startup founders consider raising capital through a Simple Agreement for Future Equity (SAFE), one of the most critical questions they face is understanding exactly how these instruments will convert in various scenarios. While much attention focuses on how SAFEs convert in successful equity financing rounds, the mechanics of conversion during acquisitions and down rounds are equally important—and often overlooked. Different types of SAFEs exist (Pre-Money vs Post-Money, with Discount, Valuation Cap, or both). See more in-depth discussion here. This post analyzes, as an example, the conversion mechanics of the Y Combinator Post-Money SAFE with Valuation Cap (the "YC SAFE"), which now appears to be one of the most commonly used SAFE forms in the venture community. That said, founders and SAFE investors should always check the specific SAFE document, as some may specify different details for liquidity events and qualified equity financings.
Understanding SAFE Conversion Fundamentals
Before diving into specific conversion scenarios, it's essential to understand that a SAFE is fundamentally a contractual right to receive equity in the future, not equity itself. The YC SAFE creates specific conversion triggers that determine when and how the instrument converts into actual shares. These triggers are carefully defined in the document and include "Equity Financing", "Liquidity Event", and "Dissolution Event".
The YC SAFE operates on a straightforward principle: it provides investors with the right to convert their investment into shares at either the price established in a future equity round or at a price determined by the valuation cap, whichever is more favorable to the investor. This protection mechanism ensures that early investors receive appropriate compensation for taking on the risk of investing in an early-stage company. In summary, conversion is always at the more advantageous price for the investor.
SAFE Conversion in Acquisition Scenarios
When a startup is acquired before raising a priced equity round, the SAFE conversion mechanics become particularly important. The YC SAFE defines this scenario as a "Liquidity Event," which includes a Change of Control, Direct Listing, or Initial Public Offering. Understanding how the SAFE converts in these situations is crucial for founders who may find themselves in acquisition discussions before completing a traditional Series A or other priced round.
According to the YC SAFE, in a Liquidity Event, "the Investor will automatically be entitled (subject to the liquidation priority set forth in Section 1(d) below) to receive a portion of Proceeds, due and payable to the Investor immediately prior to, or concurrent with, the consummation of such Liquidity Event, equal to the greater of (i) the Purchase Amount (the 'Cash-Out Amount') or (ii) the amount payable on the number of shares of Common Stock equal to the Purchase Amount divided by the Liquidity Price (the 'Conversion Amount')."
To simplify, SAFE holders have two choices upon an acquisition:
Receive their original investment amount back (the "Cash Out Amount"); or
Convert the SAFE into shares immediately prior to the acquisition (using the conversion formula as if a priced round had occurred) (the "Conversion Amount")
The SAFE holder receives whichever amount is greater, providing downside protection while allowing for upside participation.
For a post-Money SAFE (like the YC SAFE) , conversion is based on the ownership percentage implied by the cap and the original investment amount.
Example 1: SAFE holder invests $1M into a post-money SAFE with $10M valuation cap. Immediately after, the Company is being acquired for $7M, which is lower than the valuation cap.
Cash Out Amount = $1M
Conversion Amount = 10% x $7M = $700,000
SAFE Holder's Payout: SAFE holder will choose to receive the Cash Out Amount because it is higher than the Conversion Amount.
Example 2: SAFE holder invests $1M into a post-money SAFE with $10M valuation cap. Immediately after, the Company is being acquired for $10M, which is the same as the valuation cap.
Cash Out Amount = $1M
Conversion Amount = 10% x $10M = $1M
SAFE Holder's Payout: SAFE Holder will receive $1M in acquisition proceed as Cash Out Amount and Conversion Amount are the same
Example 3: SAFE holder invests $1M into a post-money SAFE with $10M valuation cap. Immediately after, the Company is being acquired for $20M, which is higher than the valuation cap.
Cash Out Amount = $1M
Conversion Amount = $1M/ Liquidity Price
The Liquidity Price calculation is where the valuation cap becomes critical. The YC SAFE defines Liquidity Price as "the price per share equal to the Post-Money Valuation Cap divided by the Liquidity Capitalization." This means that if the acquisition values the company above the SAFE's valuation cap, the SAFE holder benefits from the cap protection. The Liquidity Price would be calculated based on the $10M cap, not the $20M acquisition price, giving the SAFE holder a larger percentage of the acquisition proceeds than they would receive based on the actual acquisition valuation.
SAFE Holder's Payout: SAFE Holder will receive the Conversion Amount, which is going to be higher than the Cash Out Amount.
Liquidation Priority
The liquidation priority provisions add another layer of complexity to acquisition scenarios. The SAFE document specifies that the investor's right to receive the Cash-Out Amount is "Junior to payment of outstanding indebtedness and creditor claims, including contractual claims for payment and convertible promissory notes (to the extent such convertible promissory notes are not actually or notionally converted into Capital Stock); On par with payments for other Safes and/or Preferred Stock; and Senior to payments for Common Stock."
This priority structure means that in an acquisition, SAFE holders are treated similarly to preferred stockholders for purposes of the Cash-Out Amount, but their Conversion Amount rights are treated on par with common stockholders. This dual treatment can significantly impact the actual payout SAFE holders receive, particularly in acquisitions where the proceeds are insufficient to provide full returns to all stakeholders.
Down Round Conversion Mechanics
If a SAFE has a valuation cap and the company raises a down round (i.e., the new financing round’s valuation is lower than the valuation cap and possibly lower than a previous round), the SAFE converts at the actual, lower down round valuation—not at its valuation cap. The cap only benefits the SAFE holder if the next round's valuation is higher than the Cap.
Example 4: SAFE holder invests $1M into a post-money SAFE with $10M valuation cap. Immediately after, the Company raises a down round with pre-money valuation of $7M, which is lower than the valuation cap.
SAFE will convert at $7M value (the down round price).
This structure protects SAFE investors during rapid company growth (by capping conversion at a low value) but offers less advantage during down rounds, as the conversion price may be lower than the cap and thus simply matches the down round.
The Role of Company Capitalization in Conversion Calculations
Company Capitalization calculation is crucial for SAFE conversion outcomes, especially with multiple securities types. The Y Combinator SAFE defines Company Capitalization as "all shares of Capital Stock issued and outstanding; all Converting Securities; all (i) issued and outstanding Options and (ii) Promised Options; and the Unissued Option Pool, except that any increase to the Unissued Option Pool in connection with the Equity Financing will only be included to the extent that the number of Promised Options exceeds the Unissued Option Pool prior to such increase."
This definition ensures Safe Price calculation accounts for the company's full capitalization structure—issued shares, outstanding options, warrants, and other convertible securities. Including Converting Securities means multiple SAFEs and convertible instruments are all considered when determining conversion price, preventing any single SAFE from receiving an advantageous rate.
The option pool treatment is particularly nuanced. The SAFE includes the existing option pool and promised options, but provides specific rules for option pool increases during equity financing.
Understanding these calculations is essential for founders because they directly impact dilution when SAFEs convert. Larger Company Capitalization results in lower Safe Price, meaning SAFE holders receive more shares. Smaller Company Capitalization results in higher Safe Price and fewer shares for SAFE holders. A good lawyer shall be able to negotiate the definition of "Company Capitalization" to maximize founders or SAFE holders' interests, depending on the legal representation.
Liquidity Capitalization and Its Impact on Acquisition Scenarios
While Company Capitalization governs equity financing conversions, Liquidity Capitalization determines conversion outcomes in acquisitions. The YC SAFE defines Liquidity Capitalization differently from Company Capitalization, reflecting different considerations when a company is acquired rather than raising equity.
Liquidity Capitalization "includes all shares of Capital Stock issued and outstanding; all (i) issued and outstanding Options and (ii) to the extent receiving Proceeds, Promised Options; all Converting Securities, other than any Safes and other convertible securities (including without limitation shares of Preferred Stock) where the holders of such securities are receiving Cash-Out Amounts or similar liquidation preference payments in lieu of Conversion Amounts or similar 'as-converted' payments; and excludes the Unissued Option Pool."
The key difference lies in treating securities whose holders receive liquidation preferences rather than converting to common stock. In an acquisition, some security holders may choose their liquidation preference (similar to the Cash-Out Amount for SAFE holders) rather than converting to common stock and participating in acquisition proceeds on an as-converted basis.
This distinction matters when calculating the Liquidity Price because it affects the denominator. Securities receiving liquidation preferences are excluded from Liquidity Capitalization, which can result in a higher Liquidity Price.
Excluding the Unissued Option Pool from Liquidity Capitalization also differs from Company Capitalization. This exclusion recognizes that unissued options typically don't participate in acquisition proceeds, so they shouldn't dilute conversion calculations for securities that do participate.
Practical Implications for Founders
Understanding SAFE conversion mechanics has practical implications beyond technical conversion calculations. For founders raising capital through SAFEs, these mechanics should influence both negotiated terms and long-term strategic planning.
When negotiating SAFE terms, founders should carefully consider the post-money valuation cap given expected future financing and exit scenarios. A reasonable valuation cap in the current fundraising environment may disappoint SAFE investors in a down round or acquisition below the cap. Conversely, setting the cap too high may discourage SAFE investors seeking meaningful protection.
The conversion mechanics also affect future equity financing rounds. Founders should model how SAFE conversions will impact their ownership percentage and other stakeholders' ownership in various scenarios. This modeling should consider how conversion mechanics might affect the company's attractiveness to future investors.
In acquisition scenarios, founders should understand how SAFE conversion mechanics affect distribution of acquisition proceeds. The dual nature of SAFE conversion rights (Cash-Out Amount versus Conversion Amount) means SAFE holders may receive different treatment depending on acquisition structure and valuation. Founders should work with legal and financial advisors to model these scenarios and understand how they might affect negotiations with potential acquirers.
Considering raising a SAFE round? Let's talk.